|
Find Authors
Adelman, Ken
Amerling, Richard
Andrews, Lori
Arnett, Jr., MD, Jerome
Arnold, Mary
Aronson, Jacob
Arrison, Sonia
Arthurs, William
Axe, David
Bailey, Ronald
Bainbridge, Stephen
Balfour, Brian
Baliunas, Sallie
Balko, Radley
Ball, Carlos
Ball, Tim
Balling, Robert
Ballon, Daniel
Bandow, Doug
Bandyk, Matt
Barfield, Claude
Barro, Josh
Bate, Roger
Bay, Austin
Benham, James
Bennett, Ralph Kinney
Berlau, John
Bernard, Michelle
Berndt, Colleen
Billingsley, K. Lloyd
Birrell, Kristyn
Blinick, Adam
Boone, Mark
Borders, Max
Bowyer, Jerry
Bowyer, Chris
Bryant, Jay
Bryce, Robert
Burgess-Jackson, Keith
Calfee, John
Calhoun, Joseph
Callanan, Martin
Callick, Rowan
Campos, Paul
Cannon, Michael
Caplan, Bryan
Cecire, Michael
Chamberlain, Andrew
Chapman, John
Charat, Sylvain
Charles, David
Chumley, Cheryl
Clark, Ian
Clark, Ph.D., R.D., FACSM**, Kristine
Clifton, Daniel
Close, Carl
Cohen, Ariel
Cook, Michael
Cooper, Horace
Costello, Bill
Coulson, Andrew
Coulson, Andrew
Cox, Patrick
Cunningham, Walter
Cuthbertson, Peter
Cuzán, Alfred
D'Aleo, Joseph
Davis, Robert
de Rugy, Veronique
DeLong, James
DiGennaro, Joann
Dolinar, Richard
Dowd, Alan
Driessen, Paul
Driscoll, Edward
Dunn, Robert
Durstewitz , Jeff
Elder, Joshua
Elliott, Tom
Fein, Bruce
Finny, Charles
Foust, Joshua
France, Amanda
Freese, Duane
Fridson, Martin
Fumento, Michael
Furchtgott-Roth, Diana
Gaesser, Ph.D, Glenn
Gelinas, Nicole
George A. Pieler, Jens F. Laurson &
Giglio, Joseph
Gillespie, Nick
Glassman, James
Glover, Peter
Godsey, William
Goeller, Joseph Tom
Gratzer, David
Gray, William
Green, Stephen
Green, Kenneth
Griswold, Daniel
Gurdgiev, Constantin
Haddick, Robert
Hall, Jon
Hammond, Tim
Hanks, Micah
Hanscom, Aaron
Hansen, Andy
Harris, Marilyn
Harris, Lee
Hassett, Kevin
Hayashi, Stuart
Henderson, David
Hendrickson, Josh
Higgins, Sean
Horn, Karen
Horn, Karen
Horner, Christopher
Hull, Christopher
Hunter, Derek
Ingdahl, Waldemar
Irfan Al-Alawi, Stephen Schwartz &
Jackson, Lester
Jacobs, Joanne
James, Sallie
Jeff Stier, Dr. Henry I. Miller and
Johannes, J.D.
Johnson, Allen
Johnson, Allen
Joyner, James
Kane, David
Karlsson, Kristian
Karnick, S.T.
Kava, Ruth
Kemp, Jack
Kengor, Paul
Kern, Douglas
Kessler, Andy
Kitsing, Meelis
Klich, Bogdan
Kling, Arnold
Koehler, Benedikt
Kogan, Lawrence
Kohout, Pavel
Krauss, Michael
Krol, Robert
Kudlow, Larry
Kuhl, Jackson
Labohm, Hans
Laksin, Jacob
Legates, David
Levy, Philip
Lieberman, Ben
Liebling, Barry
Lingle, Christopher
Livestro, Joshua
Llosa, Alvaro
Luik, John
Lupo, Anthony
MacQueen, Val
Malanga, Steven
Marco, Jose Maria
Marshner, Connie
Marszal , Andrew
Martin, Maureen
Marxsen, Craig
McHenry, Robert
McKeon, Rep. Howard
Mejia-Vergnaud, Andres
Methvin, Eugene
Michael Economides, Peter Glover and
Michaels, Patrick
Miks, Jason
Miller, Henry
Miller, James
Miller, Judith
Morse, Carroll Andrew
Mounicq, Jean-Christophe
Murray, Iain
Newman, Tim
O'Brien, James
O'Connor, Philip
O'Toole, Randal
Oxley, Alan
Pajer, Kamila
Patterson, Tim
Paul, Adam
Paul Howard, Douglas Holtz-Eakin &
Pazameta, Zoran
Peckich, Jodi
Peiser, Benny
Pham, J. Peter
Pinkerton, James
Pirie, Madsen
Poller, Nidra
Price, Bruce
Proft, Dan
Rahn, Richard
Raia, Jack
Rasmussen, Henrik
Readmond, Tom
Rehmke, Greg
Reinhoudt, Jurgen
Reisman, Jon
Reiter, Paul
Reitz, Karl
Renehan, Edward
Resendes, Rafael
Reynolds, Glenn Harlan
Ringo, James
Robinson, Ron
Robison, PhD, MS, Jonathan
Roff, Peter
Roodhouse, Elizabeth
Rosen, Michael
Rosenthal, John
Ross, Gilbert
Rusin, David
Ryan, Johnny
Sager, Ryan
Sands, Emily
Satel, Sally
Schaefer, Peter F.
Scheske, Eric
Schulz, Max
Schulz, Nick
Schwartz, Joel
Schwartz, Stephen
Schwartz, Brian
Scoblete, Gregory
Selengut, Steven
Shah, Apoorva
Shapiro, Ilya
Sharp, Gary
Silber, Kenneth
Simberg, Rand
Sinclair, Matthew
Sinclair, Matthew
Singleton, Solveig
Smalkin, Kate
Smith, Andrew
Snoen, Jan Arlid
Soon, Willie
Sorman, Guy
Spain, Robert
Sparks, Evan
Sparks, Evan
Spencer, Roy
Stagnaro, Carlo
Standish, Alex
Stanek, Steve
Stanton, Stephen
Stephens, Hampton
Stewart, Mark
Storer, Mark
Swarup, Arjun
Szwarc, Sandy
Taylor, George
Teluk, Tomasz
Terpstra , B.P.
Tilley, Richard
Tren, Richard
Tupy, Marian
Turner, Frederick
Vickers, Melana Zyla
Vogel, T.K.
Volk, Anna
Voorhees, Erik
Wager, Robert
Walker, Jesse
Werbach, Kevin
Wexler, Randell
Whaples, Robert
Whelan, Elizabeth
Williamson, Richard
Wilson, Bruce
Wilson, Doug
Wilson, Bill
Winneker, Craig
Worstall, Tim
Yates, Brock
Young, Michael
Yousefzadeh, Pejman
Zuck, Jonathan
Zycher, Benjamin
Find Issues
Development and Globalization
Economics and Regulation
Energy and Environment
Health and Medicine
Intellectual Property
Internet, Communications and Media
Investing and Ownership Society
National Security and Foreign Affairs
Politics and Law
Science and Technology
Education
Location:
Home
» The Fatal Conceit Revisited
The Fatal Conceit Revisited
Font Size:
Co-Authored by:Daniel B. Klein
By Fred E. Foldvary :
BIO
| 17 Feb 2003
Discuss This Story!
(0)
Email
|
Print
|
Bookmark
|
Save
Only you know the fine points of your life. Only you know the changing details. Only you can know.
That's one of the classic economic arguments against government intervention. The vital stuff of the economy is unknowable to bureaucrats and politicians - and even to intellectuals and academics. Economic conditions and opportunities vary infinitely in time and place and, if grasped at all, are known to dispersed individuals with different facts and interpretations. The great economists Adam Smith and Friedrich Hayek concluded that the way to capitalize on market opportunities is to leave individuals free to act on their local knowledge.
But maybe technology can give policymakers the knowledge they need. Technology certainly enhances the informational capabilities of regulators. Can governments then improve markets by managing the economy?
Some might claim that we simply need to make sure the regulators are good people, working in the public interest. Does that mean we lay down arms against regulators and let them put their technology-enhanced competence to work for us?
No. Adam Smith and Frederich Hayek remain as vital as ever. For technology strengthens the case for decontrolling the economy, no matter the advantages it may afford to the regulator. That's because technology enhances the capabilities of all facets of the economy, and the magnitude and rapidity of these decentralized connections expands greatly. The whole becomes much more complex than ever before.
Technology enhances the regulator's informational capabilities. But at the same time it complicates what it is the regulator seeks to know. An economy is more complex when it has more members and more interaction among them. Also, there is a greater variety of products, finer division of labor and capital goods, and more and varied communications among people. The pace of change accelerates.
Local workers, managers, and customers know their products and relationships. There are intuitive skills, information, and communications that even the people involved are not fully aware of and could not fully articulate. Each person's knowledge changes day by day. So, even if government had an army of data-gatherers, it could not possibly keep current with the data, let alone interpret it to create a coherent and useful interventionist policy.
It is not a matter of having better data collection and bigger computers. The basic fact is that greater complexity makes the processes increasingly unknowable. "Data" presuppose a scheme of classification, a formulation of categories, a practice of deciding what will be counted as what. Greater complexity makes any interpretation of the whole less complete and less definitive. The economic cosmos is unknowable because the categories of goods and services become so multitudinous and the relations among them impossible to interpret in any useful way by central authority.
Because the hardest part of knowing is, not merely getting the facts, but getting the interpretation right, the complexity that technology brings tends to outstrip the informational capabilities of the regulator. The economy is less "masterable", not more.
Except in the most clear-cut cases of systemic harm, such as pollution, the idea that government officials can figure out how to improve upon the results of decentralized, voluntary decision-making becomes more and more questionable. In his Nobel lecture, Hayek called that supposition the "pretense of knowledge."
The economy is like the complex patterns of skating in a skating rink. Hayek called it a spontaneous order, as all the actors-consumers, investors, employees, managers, entrepreneurs-plan and act spontaneously on the basis of their local conditions. As with the skating rink, there is order in the market, so that resources are used and allocated in ways that people demonstrably want. Food from all over the planet ends up neatly packaged at your local supermarket, and people manage to commute from many origins to many destinations without a central hand to direct them.
When thinkers ponder the complex workings of the social world, they really know little aside from one hardy maxim: If those who participate in an activity do so voluntarily, each is probably bettering his own condition. The more complex the system, the more skeptical we ought to be about claims to knowledge that go beyond and against that maxim.
Fred Foldvary and Daniel Klein are economics professors at Santa Clara University and co-editors of the book "The Half-Life of Policy Rationales: How New Technology Affects Old Policy Issues" (Cato Institute/New York University Press, 2003), which will be released in March 2003.
Discuss This Story!
(0)
Email
|
Print
|
Bookmark
|
Save
Tax-Tax-Tax, Spend-Spend-Spend
Time for a Change at the Fed
Obama's Bank Bumble
Why the Bank Tax Won't Fix Wall St.
Enough Is Enough—Time to De-stimulate
More articles on this issue
»
Send Me an Alert
When TCS Publishes Articles On This Issue
Virtual Barbed Wire
More articles by this author
»
Send Me an Alert
When TCS Publishes Articles By This Author
©2000-2010 TCS Daily |
Home
|
Contact TCS
|
About TCS
|
Issues
|
Links
|
Submissions
|
Toolbox
|
Legal
|
Reprints
|
Advertise with TCS