|
Find Authors
Adelman, Ken
Andrews, Lori
Arnett, Jr., MD, Jerome
Aronson, Jacob
Arrison, Sonia
Axe, David
Bailey, Ronald
Bainbridge, Stephen
Baliunas, Sallie
Balko, Radley
Ball, Carlos
Ball, Tim
Balling, Robert
Bandow, Doug
Bandyk, Matt
Barfield, Claude
Bate, Roger
Bay, Austin
Benham, James
Bennett, Ralph Kinney
Berlau, John
Bernard, Michelle
Berndt, Colleen
Billingsley, K. Lloyd
Birrell, Kristyn
Blinick, Adam
Borders, Max
Bowyer, Jerry
Bryant, Jay
Burgess-Jackson, Keith
Calfee, John
Calhoun, Joseph
Callanan, Martin
Callick, Rowan
Campos, Paul
Cannon, Michael
Caplan, Bryan
Chamberlain, Andrew
Chapman, John
Charat, Sylvain
Charles, David
Clark, Ian
Clark, Ph.D., R.D., FACSM**, Kristine
Clifton, Daniel
Close, Carl
Cohen, Ariel
Cook, Michael
Cooper, Horace
Coulson, Andrew
Coulson, Andrew
Cox, Patrick
Cunningham, Walter
Cuthbertson, Peter
D'Aleo, Joseph
Davis, Robert
de Rugy, Veronique
DeLong, James
Driessen, Paul
Driscoll, Edward
Dunn, Robert
Durstewitz , Jeff
Elder, Joshua
Elliott, Tom
Fein, Bruce
Finny, Charles
Foust, Joshua
Freese, Duane
Fridson, Martin
Fumento, Michael
Gaesser, Ph.D, Glenn
Giglio, Joseph
Gillespie, Nick
Glassman, James
Godsey, William
Goeller, Joseph Tom
Gray, William
Green, Stephen
Green, Kenneth
Griswold, Daniel
Gurdgiev, Constantin
Haddick, Robert
Hall, Jon
Hanks, Micah
Hanscom, Aaron
Harris, Marilyn
Harris, Lee
Hassett, Kevin
Hayashi, Stuart
Henderson, David
Hendrickson, Josh
Higgins, Sean
Horner, Christopher
Hull, Christopher
Hunter, Derek
Ingdahl, Waldemar
Jacobs, Joanne
James, Sallie
Johannes, J.D.
Joyner, James
Karlsson, Kristian
Karnick, S.T.
Kava, Ruth
Kemp, Jack
Kengor, Paul
Kern, Douglas
Kessler, Andy
Kitsing, Meelis
Klich, Bogdan
Kling, Arnold
Koehler, Benedikt
Kogan, Lawrence
Kohout, Pavel
Krauss, Michael
Krol, Robert
Kuhl, Jackson
Labohm, Hans
Laksin, Jacob
Legates, David
Levy, Philip
Lieberman, Ben
Lingle, Christopher
Livestro, Joshua
Llosa, Alvaro
Luik, John
Lupo, Anthony
MacQueen, Val
Marco, Jose Maria
Martin, Maureen
Marxsen, Craig
McHenry, Robert
Mejia-Vergnaud, Andres
Methvin, Eugene
Michaels, Patrick
Miks, Jason
Miller, Henry
Miller, James
Morse, Carroll Andrew
Mounicq, Jean-Christophe
Murray, Iain
Newman, Tim
O'Brien, James
O'Connor, Philip
O'Toole, Randal
Oxley, Alan
Pajer, Kamila
Patterson, Tim
Peckich, Jodi
Peiser, Benny
Pham, J. Peter
Pinkerton, James
Pirie, Madsen
Poller, Nidra
Rahn, Richard
Raia, Jack
Rasmussen, Henrik
Readmond, Tom
Rehmke, Greg
Reinhoudt, Jurgen
Reisman, Jon
Reiter, Paul
Reitz, Karl
Renehan, Edward
Reynolds, Glenn Harlan
Ringo, James
Robison, PhD, MS, Jonathan
Roff, Peter
Roodhouse, Elizabeth
Rosen, Michael
Rosenthal, John
Ross, Gilbert
Rusin, David
Ryan, Johnny
Sager, Ryan
Sands, Emily
Satel, Sally
Scheske, Eric
Schulz, Max
Schulz, Nick
Schwartz, Joel
Schwartz, Stephen
Scoblete, Gregory
Shah, Apoorva
Shapiro, Ilya
Sharp, Gary
Silber, Kenneth
Simberg, Rand
Sinclair, Matthew
Sinclair, Matthew
Smalkin, Kate
Snoen, Jan Arlid
Soon, Willie
Spain, Robert
Sparks, Evan
Sparks, Evan
Spencer, Roy
Stagnaro, Carlo
Standish, Alex
Stanek, Steve
Stanton, Stephen
Stephens, Hampton
Storer, Mark
Szwarc, Sandy
Taylor, George
Teluk, Tomasz
Tilley, Richard
Tren, Richard
Tupy, Marian
Turner, Frederick
Vickers, Melana Zyla
Vogel, T.K.
Volk, Anna
Wager, Robert
Walker, Jesse
Werbach, Kevin
Wexler, Randell
Whaples, Robert
Whelan, Elizabeth
Wilson, Bruce
Winneker, Craig
Worstall, Tim
Yates, Brock
Young, Michael
Yousefzadeh, Pejman
Zuck, Jonathan
Zycher, Benjamin
Find Issues
Development and Globalization
Economics and Regulation
Energy and Environment
Health and Medicine
Intellectual Property
Internet, Communications and Media
Investing and Ownership Society
National Security and Foreign Affairs
Politics and Law
Science and Technology
Location:
Home
» Article
A Diagnosis of Corporate Pathologies
Font Size:
By John Baden :
BIO
| 22 Oct 2020
Discuss This Story!
(11)
Email
|
Print
|
Bookmark
|
Save
Economists have no monopoly on tools explaining the pathologies that afflict organizations. However, their approach offers some illuminating insights. Here's one -- within an organization decisions are made on the basis of information and incentives faced by the decision maker.
Consider business practices that alienate customers and clients. Surely no business with a general clientele, such as Amazon, Home Depot, or Kmart, has this as a goal. Yet it occurs. Why?
The offending employee may be evil, bitter, or malicious, but economists have little to say about individual characteristics. Rather, economists examine the incentives and information facing the person who annoyed or harmed the customer. Here are two examples.
The Wall Street Journal
recently featured an account by Laura Landro, one of their senior editors. In preparation for her granddaughter Emily's new school term, Landro, who is responsible for all New York reporters covering the media and marketing, took her shopping at Kmart. Her and Emily's mother together spent "more than $800." When they went to pay at the register, their haul included a pair of loose flip-flops that had, in error, been put in the wrong box. Big mistake. Landro was accused of cheating the store out of $8.
She notes, "retailers face a daily battle against scam artists. But let the customer beware: With security on high alert, even law-abiding shoppers can fall under suspicion." Eight dollar error detected, she was taken to a security room, detained for an hour, and accused of deliberately switching a more expensive item into a cheaper box. Her driver's license and credit card were temporarily confiscated. She was told to expect a civil notice of a fine and the security guard "Š told me I couldn't come back to the store; I assured him I had no intention of returning to any Kmart, ever."
The security guard did nothing wrong; he had incentives to follow company policy and he did so. The results, however, were surely perverse. While Kmart's practices no doubt reduce shrinkage generated by price switching, if misapplied, they drive good customers away.
Customers like me... I have spent too many thousands of dollars on Amazon.com and, until recently, never had a problem. They advise me of new books reflecting my interests based on my purchasing history. I have a weakness, perhaps an addiction, for books.
Earlier this year I received notice of an Amazon credit card that offered special privileges and discounts. I signed up, and placed an order.
I always immediately pay credit card bills. A bill with my initial charge of $43.08 never arrived. The first statement received included a late fee of $15.00 and a $1.00 finance charge. I, of course, protested. Alas to no avail.
I first sent a letter protesting. Then called and went through an interminable phone tree. Then wrote again, and called again, and again. And then canceled my card and received another late fee added to the first. It was clear that I would not receive satisfaction.
I often lunch with my primary banker and shared my plight and genuine anger at Amazon with him. Suddenly, with his help, the problem became clear.
My new Amazon card wasn't really with Amazon. Rather it was a Chase Bank "affinity card" sponsored by Amazon. Apparently, Amazon has an arrangement with Chase to offer this card. In return it receives some small percentage of each charge.
The bank has many such affinity cards. The person receiving complaints about charges has incentives to collect all payments, late charges, penalties, etc. He has no interest in customers' feelings toward Amazon or any other company. It is likely his performance is measured by the charges he collects.
In this case, Amazon's CFO no doubt saw an opportunity to add a small percentage to each sale by establishing an affinity card operated by Chase Bank. There is no system to note and correct sorry treatment to customers.
Huge organizations create policies that look good at headquarters. However, they often have negative consequences at the individual level.
Discuss This Story!
(11)
Email
|
Print
|
Bookmark
|
Save
Unions Grasp for Influence Over Private Equity
So You Want to be a Masonomist
The Risk Disclosure Problem
Trading Exaggerations
Mr. Trichet Sleeps as the Dollar Sinks
More articles on this issue
»
Send Me an Alert
When TCS Publishes Articles On This Issue
The Terror of Ethanol
Judge Not
Economics for Ecologists
SUVs and the Clash of Cultures
Marines' Machines
More articles by this author
»
Send Me an Alert
When TCS Publishes Articles By This Author
Unwarranted Intrusions: The Case Against Government Intervention in the Marketplace
The Long Tail: Why the Future of Business Is Selling Less of More
CFROI Cash Flow Return on Investment Valuation: A Total System Approach to Valuing the Firm
Go to TCS Bookshelf
»
©2000-2007 TCS Daily |
Home
|
Contact TCS
|
About TCS
|
Issues
|
Links
|
Submissions
|
Toolbox
|
Legal
|
Reprints
|
Advertise with TCS