|
Find Authors
Adelman, Ken
Arrison, Sonia
Axe, David
Bailey, Ronald
Bainbridge, Stephen
Baliunas, Sallie
Balko, Radley
Ball, Carlos
Ball, Tim
Balling, Robert
Bandow, Doug
Barfield, Claude
Bate, Roger
Bay, Austin
Bennett, Ralph Kinney
Berlau, John
Borders, Max
Bowyer, Jerry
Bryant, Jay
Burgess-Jackson, Keith
Calfee, John
Callanan, Martin
Callick, Rowan
Campos, Paul
Charat, Sylvain
Charles, David
Clark, Ian
Clark, Ph.D., R.D., FACSM**, Kristine
Clifton, Daniel
Close, Carl
Cohen, Ariel
Cook, Michael
Cooper, Horace
Coulson, Andrew
Cox, Patrick
Cunningham, Walter
D'Aleo, Joseph
Davis, Robert
de Rugy, Veronique
DeLong, James
Driessen, Paul
Driscoll, Edward
Elder, Joshua
Fein, Bruce
Finny, Charles
Foust, Joshua
Freese, Duane
Fridson, Martin
Fumento, Michael
Gaesser, Ph.D, Glenn
Gillespie, Nick
Glassman, James
Godsey, William
Goeller, Joseph Tom
Gray, William
Green, Stephen
Green, Kenneth
Griswold, Daniel
Gurdgiev, Constantin
Haddick, Robert
Harris, Marilyn
Harris, Lee
Hassett, Kevin
Hayashi, Stuart
Henderson, David
Hendrickson, Josh
Horner, Christopher
Hull, Christopher
Ingdahl, Waldemar
Jacobs, Joanne
Joyner, James
Karlsson, Kristian
Karnick, S.T.
Kava, Ruth
Kemp, Jack
Kengor, Paul
Kern, Douglas
Kessler, Andy
Kitsing, Meelis
Klich, Bogdan
Kling, Arnold
Koehler, Benedikt
Kogan, Lawrence
Kohout, Pavel
Krauss, Michael
Krol, Robert
Kuhl, Jackson
Labohm, Hans
Laksin, Jacob
Legates, David
Lieberman, Ben
Lingle, Christopher
Livestro, Joshua
Llosa, Alvaro
Luik, John
Lupo, Anthony
MacQueen, Val
Marco, Jose Maria
McHenry, Robert
Mejia-Vergnaud, Andres
Michaels, Patrick
Miks, Jason
Miller, Henry
Miller, James
Morse, Carroll Andrew
Mounicq, Jean-Christophe
Murray, Iain
O'Brien, James
O'Connor, Philip
Oxley, Alan
Pajer, Kamila
Patterson, Tim
Peckich, Jodi
Pham, J. Peter
Pinkerton, James
Pirie, Madsen
Poller, Nidra
Rasmussen, Henrik
Readmond, Tom
Reisman, Jon
Reiter, Paul
Renehan, Edward
Reynolds, Glenn Harlan
Ringo, James
Robison, PhD, MS, Jonathan
Rosen, Michael
Rosenthal, John
Ross, Gilbert
Sager, Ryan
Satel, Sally
Schulz, Nick
Schulz, Max
Schwartz, Joel
Schwartz, Stephen
Scoblete, Gregory
Shapiro, Ilya
Sharp, Gary
Silber, Kenneth
Simberg, Rand
Snoen, Jan Arlid
Soon, Willie
Spain, Robert
Spencer, Roy
Stagnaro, Carlo
Standish, Alex
Stanton, Stephen
Stephens, Hampton
Storer, Mark
Szwarc, Sandy
Taylor, George
Teluk, Tomasz
Tren, Richard
Tupy, Marian
Turner, Frederick
Vickers, Melana Zyla
Vogel, T.K.
Volk, Anna
Walker, Jesse
Werbach, Kevin
Wexler, Randell
Whaples, Robert
Whelan, Elizabeth
Winneker, Craig
Worstall, Tim
Yates, Brock
Young, Michael
Yousefzadeh, Pejman
Zuck, Jonathan
Zycher, Benjamin
Find Issues
Development and Globalization
Economics and Regulation
Energy and Environment
Health and Medicine
Intellectual Property
Internet, Communications and Media
Investing and Ownership Society
National Security and Foreign Affairs
Politics and Law
Science and Technology
Location:
Home
» Article
How to Make Our Food Safer
Font Size:
By Dr. Henry I. Miller :
BIO
| 06 Nov 2020
Discuss This Story!
(9)
Email
|
Print
|
Bookmark
|
Save
Food poisoning from food contaminated with microorganisms is very common: 76
million
cases and 5,000 deaths annually in the United States, according to government figures.
A couple of recent outbreaks have garnered a lot of attention. During the past two months, there have been three deaths and approximately 200 cases of illness from
E. coli
O157:H7 (traced to fresh, bagged spinach), and about 200 illnesses caused by
Salmonella typhimurium
.
Federal officials investigating the spinach outbreak have narrowed their search to a handful of ranches in California's Salinas Valley and appear to be focusing on wild hogs as the cause of contamination. The source of the Salmonella contamination is as yet unknown.
Americans are wondering who will protect us from future outbreaks of contamination and food-borne illness.
First, it's clear we can't rely on growers of fresh produce to protect us 100 percent of the time. Modern farming operations - especially the larger ones -- already employ strict standards and safeguards designed to keep food free of pathogens. And most often they work: Americans' food is not only the least expensive, but also the safest, in the history of humankind.
However, there is a limit to how safe we can make agriculture, given that it is an outdoor activity and subject to all manner of unpredictable challenges. If the goal is to make a field 100 percent safe from contamination, the only solution that guarantees this is to pave it over and build a parking lot on it. But we'd only be trading very rare agricultural mishaps for fender-benders.
It has also become painfully clear that we can't rely on processors to remove the pathogens from food in every case. This most recent outbreak of illness demonstrated that our faith in processor labels such as "triple washed" and "ready to eat" must be tempered with at least a little skepticism. Processors were quick to proclaim the cleanliness of their own operations and deflect blame toward growers. But all of those in the food chain share responsibility for food safety and quality.
In fairness to processors, there is ample evidence to suggest that no amount of washing will rid all pathogens from produce. The reason is that the contamination may occur not
on
the plant, but
in
it. Exposure to
E. coli
or other microorganisms at key stages of the growing process may allow them to be taken into the plant and actually incorporated into cells.
Citing this, advocates of food irradiation have stepped forward to claim that their technology can provide the assurance consumers demand and deserve. To be sure, irradiation is an important tool to promote food safety and is vastly under-used, largely due to opposition from the organic food lobby and government over-regulation.
But irradiation is no panacea. Although it quite neatly kills the bacteria, it does not inactivate the potent toxins secreted by certain bacteria such as
Staphylococcus aureus
and
Clostridium botulinum
. This is a distinction you'd keenly appreciate should you become infected.
So, if consumers can't be protected by growers or processors or even irradiation, what can protect them?
There is technology available today that can inhibit microorganisms' ability to grow within plant cells and block the synthesis of the bacterial toxins. This same technology can be employed to produce antibodies that can be administered to infected patients to neutralize the toxins, and can even be used to produce therapeutic proteins that are safe and effective treatments for diarrhea, the primary symptom of food poisoning.
But don't expect your favorite organic producer to embrace this triple-threat technology, even if it would keep his customers from getting sick. Why? The technology in question is biotechnology, or gene-splicing -- an advance the organic lobby has vilified and rejected at every turn.
For organic marketers, the irony is more bitter than fresh-picked radicchio. The technology that affords them the best method of safeguarding their customers is the one they've fought hardest to forestall and confound.
Perhaps in the wake of at least three deaths and 400 illnesses from the recent
E. coli
and
S. typhimurium
outbreaks, the organic lobby will rethink its opposition to biotechnology. Perhaps they will undertake a meaningful examination of the ways in which this technology can save lives and advance their industry.
I'm not betting the farm on it. After all, admitting you're wrong is hard. Blaming others is easy.
Henry I. Miller is a physician and fellow at the Hoover Institution.
Barron's
chose his most recent book, "The Frankenfood Myth..." one of the 25 Best Books of 2004. He headed the FDA's Office of Biotechnology from 1989 to 1993.
Discuss This Story!
(9)
Email
|
Print
|
Bookmark
|
Save
Wrist Action
Appreciating Our Moral and Mental Development
The Age of Proximity
Technology on Top: Appreciating the Luxury Learning Curve
Why Michael Crichton Is Wrong About Patenting Genes
More articles on this issue
»
Send Me an Alert
When TCS Publishes Articles On This Issue
The Man for All Seasons
Are Bad Drugs Coming to a Pharmacy Near You?
Drug Testing, Drug Hazards
The Straight Dope on 'Medical Marijuana'
What's Needed at FDA
More articles by this author
»
Send Me an Alert
When TCS Publishes Articles By This Author
Natural Religion
The Day Without Yesterday: Lemaître, Einstein, and the Birth of Modern Cosmology
Freaks of the Storm: From Flying Cows to Stealing Thunder: The World's Strangest True Weather Stories
Go to TCS Bookshelf
»
©2000-2007 TCS Daily |
Home
|
Contact TCS
|
About TCS
|
Issues
|
Links
|
Submissions
|
Toolbox
|
Legal
|
Reprints
|
Advertise with TCS